Chapter 4 of 4

3 AM thoughts

Why Do We Want People We Know We Can't Have?

Nila de EvelynAug 22, 20263 min read
Why Do We Want People We Know We Can't Have?

Tap the picture to see it full size

There is something almost ridiculous about human desire. Tell us that something is available, and suddenly we have options. Tell us we cannot have it, and somehow our brains becomes a full-time detective. We start noticing every little thing about that person.
The way they laugh. The way they speak. That one message from six months ago. That tiny moment of eye contact that probably meant absolutely nothing. And suddenly our brain has produced and entire romantic universe from three seconds of interaction.
Why? Because Unavailability can make desire stranger. Psychologist Jack Brehm's research an psychological reactance showed that when people feel a freedom or choice has been taken away they can become more motivated to regain it.
In simple terms when something becomes forbidden or unavailabl, part of our brain goes, "Oh? You said I can't?. Now I definitely want it. "But there is another layer. Sometimes we don't actually want the person as much as we want the possibility of them.
When someone is available, reality eventually arrives, you discover their annoying habits. Their incompatible opinions. Their bad communication. Their ordinary days. Their flaws. But when someone is unreachable, reality cannot interrupt the fantasy.
You can fill the gaps with whatever you want. They become perfect partly because you never get enough access to discover that they aren't. That's why an impossible relationship can sometimes feel more intense than a real one. A real relationship has laundry.
An impossible relationship has a sound track. A real relationship has misunderstandings about qhobforgot to reply. An impossible relationship has you staring at the celling at 2 a.m woundering what their last Instagram story really meant.
And sometimes the thing we want isn't even the person . It is what they represent. Maybe they represent being chosen. Maybe they represent validation. Maybe they represent the version of ourselves we imagine becoming if they loved us.
Maybe getting them would prove something we secretly want to believe about ourselves.
"I was worthy enough for some like them".
That can make rejection particularly painful. Because we're losing the future we invented around them. The wedding that never happened. The conversations that never happened.
Sometimes we prefer wanting someone to actually having them. Because desire is exciting. It gives us something to anticipate. Something to fantasize about something to check our phones for.
Reality has consequences. Desire doesn't, you can love the idea of someone without having to deal with the complicated reality of loving them. But knowing this doesn't automatically make the feeling disappear.
You can understand that someone isn't right for you and still want them. You can know you cannot have them and still miss them. Feelings don't always obey conclusions.
Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is admit:
I want them
Iknow I can't have them.
And I'm going to let both things because true.
Because not every desire is a direction. Some desires are simply feelings that pass through us. And perhaps growing up is learning that wanting something badly doesn't mean it belongs in your life




When you can't have someone, do you

No votes yet

Your vote is final.

🥹 1
Comments1
minilatikaAug 29, 2026

this one hits differently because it doesn’t romanticise longing- it actually explains it. The distinction between wanting a person and wanting the possibility of them is especially striking

Nila de Evelyn

Written by

Nila de Evelyn

More by Nila de Evelyn

Short link: hurroz.com/c/D1122